Pros/Cons of Global Markets

What exactly are the benefits of a globalized art market?

The need for open, globalized visual art markets arises from the limitations and challenges posed by the alternative closed, insular markets. By embracing openness and globalization, the art market can benefit in several ways:

1. Diversity and Cultural Exchange: An open global market allows for a broader representation of artistic styles, techniques, and cultural perspectives. It enables artists from different parts of the world to share their unique visions, narratives, and artistic expressions. This diversity fosters cultural exchange and enriches the art scene with new ideas, influences, and inspirations.

2. Increased Exposure and Accessibility: A globalized art market expands the reach and visibility of artists and their works. It provides greater opportunities for artists to showcase their creations to a wider audience beyond their local or regional boundaries. This exposure can lead to increased recognition, lucrative career opportunities, and potential collaborations with international collectors, galleries, and institutions. Further, a more accessible market allows art enthusiasts and collectors from around the world to discover and appreciate a diverse range of artworks.

3. Economic Growth and Sustainability: Opening up art markets globally stimulates economic growth and sustainability. It encourages trade and transactions across borders. Increased commercial activity generates revenue streams for artists and the art industry as a whole. Moreover, it promotes the development of supportive infrastructures, such as art fairs, online platforms, and logistics services, all of which contribute to the growth of local economies and job creation.

4. Innovation and Artistic Progression: Globalization facilitates the exchange of artistic ideas, techniques, and materials. Artists can learn from different artistic traditions, experiment with diverse mediums, and incorporate new perspectives into their work. This cross-pollination of ideas fosters innovation, pushing the boundaries of artistic expression and driving artistic progression on a global scale.

5. Cultural Diplomacy and Understanding: A globalized art market serves as a powerful tool for cultural diplomacy and fosters international understanding. Art has the ability to transcend language barriers, cultural differences, and political boundaries, promoting dialogue, empathy, and mutual respect. By promoting the exchange and appreciation of art from different cultures, societies can develop a deeper understanding and appreciation of one another's perspectives, values, and heritage.

6. Balancing the Art Trade Worldwide: Most art professionals who have dealt with the international movement of works of art have long been clamoring for a globalized system, fair and equitable laws regarding taxation, customs & duty equaility, standardized documentation, built-in droit de suite provisions, and flexible On-Arrival short-term visas so that artists and/or representatives can freely travel with their works for exhibitions. Instead, many countries continue to treat consigned goods as sales and thus deem federal and sales taxes applicable upon entry. Others saddle imports with short consigment limitations that are unsuitable for galleries who need time before, during, and after shows to guarantee the best possible success for them and their artists. High initial entry costs are often exorbitant, even for goods that are either not sold or not even intended for sale. Claims for national patrimony and public cries to thwart cultural flight severely limit international opportunities even for emerging artists whose works they can only dream might some day hold a little value to the nation. Global standards for the importation and exportation of works of art would augment transparency and ease the process, especially for artists who can put their time to much better use.

Caveats

To realize the benefits of an open globalized art market, it is crucial to address challenges such as the protection of artists' rights, ethical practices, fair representation, and the preservation of cultural heritage. Implementing effective regulations, promoting transparency, supporting artists' livelihoods, and encouraging responsible collection practices can help create a more inclusive, sustainable, and equitable art market on a global scale.

Cons

1. Homogenization of Art: Globalization can lead to the standardization and homogenization of art. As art becomes more commercialized and market-driven, there may be a tendency for artists to create works that cater to popular tastes and trends, resulting in a lack of diversity and originality.

2. Inequality of Access: Globalization can further widen the gap between established art centers and emerging art scenes or underrepresented artists. Wealthy collectors and institutions based in major art capitals often have more resources and influence, while artists from marginalized regions or communities may struggle to gain recognition or access to the global art market.

3. Rampant Commercialization: The globalized art market often prioritizes financial gains over artistic value and creativity. This emphasis on profit can lead to the commodification of art, where artworks are treated as investment assets rather than cultural expressions. It can result in inflated prices, speculation, and the concentration of wealth in the hands of a few elite collectors.

4. Affronts to Cultural Identity: Globalization can potentially erode local cultural identities as artworks from different regions and traditions are commodified and consumed globally. Indigenous or traditional art forms may become marginalized or misrepresented, with a focus on art that conforms to Western or mainstream standards.

5. Art Market Bubbles and Rapid Swings: The globalized art market is susceptible to speculative bubbles, where prices of artworks are driven up artificially due to speculation and investor frenzy. Such bubbles can burst, leading to market crashes and financial losses for collectors and investors, as seen in the past with the contemporary art market.

6. Exploitation of Artists: The global art market can exacerbate power imbalances both between artists and dealers or galleries and operators in developed versus developing nations. Artists, particularly emerging ones, may face pressures to produce commercially viable art or enter unfavorable contracts due to the dominance of market forces. This can lead to exploitation, inadequate compensation, and limited creative freedom.

7. Illicit Trade and Cultural Heritage Concerns: With globalization, the demand for art from different cultures and historical periods increases. However, this demand can also fuel illicit trade, including looting, theft, forgery, and the illegal trafficking of cultural artifacts. The loss of cultural heritage and the exploitation of vulnerable communities are significant concerns associated with the globalized art market.

8. Big Fish can devour Little Fish: Open markets can inevitably lead to the major players devouring the best that smaller markets have to offer, leaving the minor art centers with little left to promote and build upon at grassroots levels. This dearth of local talent can also lead to a snowballing effect when government agencies further pull back funding for arts & culture programming.

9. Benefactors tend to always be limited to the wealthy and the connected despite the increase in global competition: Those who benefit most from globalized markets tend to be those with the resources to freely move from market to market. Artists and galleries who don't have this ability are soon at a major disadvantage. Not only can they not participate personally in international events, they are often left in vulnerable positions when they are forced to trust representatives in foreign markets to handle their work without having their own "boots on the ground" to oversee operations. The number of artists who have been bilked out of their works and their proceeds of sales are staggering, and the vast majority of the victims tend to be those from developing nations who cannot accompany their works to events in larger developed countries.

10. Unilateral Opportunities Leading to Small Market Marginalization: Given some of the concerns mentioned above, it is not uncommon for galleries and institutions, indeed entire small markets, to shelter themselves from the influences of larger art markets. Many seek self-preservation under the guise of "maintaining support for local artists and galleries," but what's often happening is leaders want to have their cake and eat it to. In other words, they want to preserve their home markets exclusively for themselves, but they also expect their artists and galleries to receive opportunities afar.

While everyone appears to be acting in good faith to build local grassroots movements before venturing into larger markets, the end result of one-sided opportunity avaiability is often the creation of insular markets that close off access to willing participants from outside. In so doing, small markets risk losing important international connections through marginalization, and they forfeit chances to enrich their own local markets even though they fully expect to be able to continue to send works freely into other important centers. Ironically, those who are impacted first are the emerging and mid-career artists who struggle to survive on tilted playig fields both at home and abroad.

*****

It is important to note that not all of these negative effects are inherent to globalization itself. Some arise from how the art market operates within the context of globalization. Efforts to promote inclusivity, ethical practices, and a more balanced representation of artists and cultural traditions can help mitigate some of these negative consequences.

*****